Papayya vs Kickoff: Online Personal Training Compared

Every workout coached live, or a coach in your pocket?

Papayya and Kickoff both pair you with a certified human coach online. They differ on how much of your training happens live, and on how you pay.

Start My Free Trial
  • 14-day free trial
  • No credit card required
  • Cancel anytime
  • 4.6 on Trustpilot
  • From $23.20 a session
  • 50,000+ live sessions coached
  • Certified, degree-holding trainers
A woman doing a squat on a mat in her living room while her trainer coaches her live on a laptop
Live 1-on-1 with your trainer

Last updated November 2026. Papayya wrote this comparison. Kickoff details come from Kickoff's own website and App Store listing.

Papayya or Kickoff: which is better for you?

Two good models, built for different people

Choose Kickoff if your health insurance covers it and you want nutrition coaching from a registered dietitian alongside app-based workouts. Choose Papayya if you want a certified trainer watching and correcting every rep in a live 1-on-1 video session, with transparent per-session pricing and no insurance paperwork.

Papayya vs Kickoff side by side

The differences at a glance

Each fact below comes from Papayya's and Kickoff's websites, checked in November 2026.

Swipe to see both columns →

FeaturePapayya

Kickoff

Coaching formatLive 1-on-1 video call for every workout

Workouts in the app, daily texts and weekly video calls

Live workouts with a trainerYes, every session

Optional live video workouts on the 55+ plan

Session length30, 45 or 60 minutes

Not session-based

Price$23.20 to $41.74 per session

$0 for most insured members; $95 a month self-pay (55+ plan)

Insurance, HSA or FSANo

Bills 100+ insurers; 55+ plan is HSA/FSA eligible

Free trial14 days, no credit card

None published

ContractNone; billed every 28 days

None; cancel in the app

App requiredNo, sessions open from a video link

Yes, workouts and messaging run in the Kickoff app

CoachesCertified, with a degree in an exercise science field; 4 to 20 years' experience

Registered dietitians and certified trainers; about 10 years' average experience

NutritionComplimentary meal plan included

Daily meal plan and macro tracking

Rating4.6 on Trustpilot

4.9 on the App Store (2.7K ratings)

Best forPeople who want form corrected live, every session

Insured people who want nutrition-led coaching

A woman sitting on an exercise mat at home, checking her training plan on a tablet, with dumbbells beside her

How Papayya live online personal training works

A trainer on the call for every rep

Papayya starts with a short questionnaire and a match with a vetted trainer from its own staff. The first session includes a posture, cardio and movement assessment. After that, each workout runs as a scheduled video call where your trainer adjusts exercises to your space and equipment as you go. Sessions book 24/7 in any time zone and reschedule with 8 hours' notice.

How Kickoff online coaching works

Daily check-ins, workouts in the app

Kickoff matches you with a coach through a quiz. Your coach builds workouts you complete on your own in the Kickoff app, with step-by-step demo videos, and you can send videos of harder moves for form feedback. Coaches text on weekdays, hold weekly video calls and write daily meal plans, with AI-assisted macro tracking in the app.

Papayya vs Kickoff cost: which is cheaper?

What you'd actually pay each month

If your insurance covers Kickoff, it will cost less than Papayya. Paying out of pocket, the gap depends on how many live sessions you want. Papayya bills every 28 days, so a cycle works out to roughly:

  • Papayya, one 30-minute session a week: about $110
  • Papayya, two 30-minute sessions a week: about $209
  • Papayya, one 60-minute session a week: about $167
  • Kickoff 55+ self-pay: $95 a month, with live video workouts optional

See how a live session feels first

14-day free trial · No credit card required · Cancel anytime

Start My Free Trial

Who should choose Papayya, and who should choose Kickoff

Match the model to how you train

Both services coach beginners through experienced exercisers, so the right pick comes down to format and budget.

  • Choose Papayya if you're new to strength training and want your form corrected live
  • Choose Papayya if you show up best for a booked appointment with a real person
  • Choose Papayya if your workday is unpredictable and you need sessions at odd hours
  • Choose Kickoff if your insurer covers it and cost decides it for you
  • Choose Kickoff if weight loss and nutrition are your main goals

Papayya reviews from live training clients

50,000+ live sessions coached

Kimberly Massey, an accountant, rated Papayya 10/10 and said online training worked better for her than her past in-person sessions.

“I was surprised to say that I found the online training more effective than in person sessions I’ve had (...) My Papayya trainer Louis has real in depth background and was able to spot within the first assessment some physical imbalances that have caused me pain and discomfort for years.”
Kimberly Massey, Accountant · Rated Papayya 10/10

Try Papayya live online personal training free

See what a coached session feels like

Answer a few questions, get matched with a Papayya trainer and book your first live session from home.

Start My Free Trial
  • 14-day free trial
  • No credit card required
  • Cancel anytime

Papayya vs Kickoff: common questions

Questions people ask before choosing

Is Kickoff live personal training?

Partly. Kickoff includes a weekly video call with your coach, and its 55+ plan lists optional 1-on-1 live video workouts, but most workouts are done on your own from the app. Papayya is the opposite: every Papayya workout is a live session, so a trainer is watching from the first rep to the last.

Is Kickoff really free?

For many people, yes. Kickoff says most clients pay $0 out of pocket because it bills insurers such as Aetna, Anthem, BlueCross BlueShield, Cigna and UnitedHealthcare, and it offers to cover co-pays. Coverage varies, so check eligibility first. Papayya doesn't depend on insurance, so the Papayya price is the same for everyone.

Is a live online personal trainer cheaper than an in-person trainer?

Usually. Kickoff's own site puts in-person trainer sessions at $100 or more, and a live 1-on-1 Papayya session costs well under half that at every plan level. Training online also removes the gym membership and travel time, so Papayya clients pay only for coaching.

Which is better for women over 50, Papayya or Kickoff?

Both work with older adults. Kickoff has a dedicated 55+ plan, while Papayya's trainers include specialists in active aging and women's health who coach strength, balance and mobility live. If you want someone watching your form as you lift heavier, Papayya's format fits better; if nutrition support comes first, Kickoff's plan does.

Do I need equipment for Papayya or Kickoff?

Neither requires a gym. Papayya needs a phone or laptop and about 7 ft by 7 ft of floor space, and your trainer works with whatever weights you own. Kickoff builds workouts for anything from no equipment to a full gym, and can fit around outdoor runs or classes you already do.

What's the best Kickoff alternative for live 1-on-1 training?

If app-and-text coaching isn't keeping you consistent, Papayya is built around the live session instead. Every Papayya trainer is a vetted staff member rather than a marketplace profile, and each one completes ongoing training in Papayya's science-based method, so the quality of coaching stays consistent from trainer to trainer.

More comparisons

Still comparing?

More comparisons are on the way.